Surface Pro 3 Pen vs Surface Pro 4 Pen Side-by-Side

Surface Pro 3 Pen vs Surface Pro 4 Pen Side-by-Side

You have probably already heard that Microsoft has changed the Pen with the new Surface Pro 4 and Surface Book. You may have even heard that the new Surface Pen will have different functionality but do you know exactly how or why it’s different from the existing Surface Pen?

Let me give you the scoop on the new pen…

UPDATE: After receiving the Surface Pro 4, I examined the pen again. There is, indeed, a side button there. It is hidden, at the lower end of the long bar that runs down the front of the pen. You have to click it in the correct area (at the end) to notice that it is there.

Surface Pro 3 Pen vs Surface Pro 4 Pen: Side-By-Side

As you can see in the picture below, the new Surface Pen (bottom) is slightly bigger than the original Surface Pro 3 Pen. You can also see that it is lacking the two buttons on the barrel of the pen. Personally, while it changes the way I work with the pen, I won’t miss them since I often accidentally press one or both when I write with the pen on my SP3.

Note: Microsoft reports that there is a second button on the SP4 Pen: “access formatting options using the right-click button on the side”, however, when I used the pen, I didn’t notice this button…hmmm…

surface pro 4 pen

Its dimensions are 5.67 x 0.37 x 0.40 in. And it weighs in at 0.7 oz. This makes it both a bit bigger and heavier than the Surface 3 version of the pen but if feels more like a real pen. From a more subjective point of view, it’s weighted very well and it gives a great pen-paper experience.

The magnetic attachment system harks back to the original Surface pro and Surface Pro 2 days. At first I was a bit apprehensive about it because my experience with the Surface Pro was that the magnets were too weak and I would often lose my stylus.

surface pro 4 pen

After playing with it, I’m happy to note that the new magnetic attachment system is much more secure. Even when I shook the SP4 in an attempt to knock the pen loose, it stayed firmly attached.

Don’t get me wrong, I would still recommend getting a physical pen loop to store the Surface Pen when it’s in your bag or briefcase because who want’s to risk losing $60? However, the magnetic attachment is really nice if you want to quickly stow your Surface Pen while you use they keyboard or touchscreen but. still have it close at hand.

If you’re more of a “black and white” person, you might find the technical specifications in the table below interesting as well.

Details Surface Pro 3 Pen Surface Pro 4 Pen
Price $49.99 $59.99
Battery 1 AAAA, 2 319 coin cell 1 AAAA
Size, weight 9.5mm x 135mm, 18g 9.5mm x 144mm, 20g
Buttons 3 2
Compatibility Surface Pro 3, Surface 3 Surface Pro 3, Surface 3, Surface Pro 4, Surface Book
Functionality Right-click, erase, OneNote Erase, Cortana, OneNote, Options
Pressure Points support 256 1,024
Attachment Cloth Loop Magnetic Grip
Pen Tip Kit No Yes: 2H, H, HB, B
In the box Surface Pen, 1 AAAA, 2 319 coin cell batteries Surface Pen with HB tip installed, Battery, Pen Tip Kit

To me, the interesting points are the backward compatibility and interchangeable pen tips so, let’s touch on those aspects next.

Surface Pro 3 Pen vs Surface Pro 4 Pen: Compatibility

It’s always nice when a manufacturer makes products compatible across multiple devices. The new Surface Pen works with the following devices:

  • Surface 3
  • Surfaces Pro 3
  • Surface Pro 4
  • Surface Book

While compatible with the Surface 3 and SP3, the SP4 and Surface Book decidedly work better with the new pen since they support 1,024 levels of pressure sensitivity screens and thinner glass whereas the Surface 3 and SP3 only offer 256 levels of sensitivity. This gives them a better writing/drawing experience and better utilization of the Pen’s tips.

Surface Pro 3 Pen vs Surface Pro 4 Pen: Interchangeable Tips

The new Surface Pen includes a Pen Tip Kit. The pen tips are 2H, H, HB, B – for a total 4 tips. This is very nice for artists since it gives them more “brushes” to use with programs like Fresh Paint.

For the majority of users, it’s still beneficial because, on occasion, folks have broken or worn down the old Surface Pen nub which often resulted in needing to purchase a whole new $50 pen. It will be nice when people can fix their (otherwise fine) pen for just a few dollars.

Surface Pro 3 Pen vs Surface Pro 4 Pen: Functionality

With the removal of two buttons, a few of you might be wondering how to do some common things with the new pen. I put together a short list for your reference below:

  • Eraser – the top button now functions like an eraser. It’s nice because it’s very intuitive.
  • One click to Cortana – a single click and hold will open Cortana – providing you have Windows 10 installed on your Surface.
  • One click to OneNote – a single click of the top button will open OneNote – just like in the past.
  • Double-click to take a screen shot – double-clicking the eraser button will still capture a screenshot and send it to OneNote.

Surface Pro 3 Pen vs Surface Pro 4 Pen: Conclusion

I was very impressed with the new Surface Pen. When I used the Surface Pro 4 and its new Pen, I was quite impressed. It handled, and felt, just like a non-digital pen or pencil – very impressive.

So, even if you aren’t planning on upgrading your SP3 to a SP4, you may still want to get the new Surface Pen for a “micro upgrade”.



Pin It on Pinterest

Share This