Surface Pro 4 vs Acer Switch Alpha 12 comparison – Design & Feel

9

Introduction

We have already published an early comparison article that compares the Surface Pro 4 and the Acer Switch Alpha 12. For the next few articles, we will go more in-depth and point out the differences.

As a starter, we will look into the design & feel of each devices.

 

Surface Pro 4 vs Acer Switch Alpha 12 – Exterior Casing

It’s pretty obvious that Acer’s goal was to create a clone of Surface Pro 4 at a lower price point. In a 2-in-1 device format such as these, there really aren’t a whole lot of options to be different.

To illustrate the point:

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_top

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_side2

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_side1

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_side3

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_side4

Although on paper the Surface Pro 4 is smaller, you really can’t feel it in person. Can you?

Surface Pro 4 vs Acer Switch Alpha 12 – Keyboard

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_keyboards_top

Predictably, the size of each keyboard is about the same as well. The size of each buttons are about the same and they feel very similar. The Switch Alpha 12’s keys are slightly clickier but both are easy to touch-type at a full speed.

As for the touch pad, the Surface Pro 4’s pad is slightly wider. But more importantly, it is located more towards the center. I like this arrangement better as a right handed person. Once again, the Switch Alpha 12 pad’s click is slightly stiffer and in terms of sensitivity, they are about the same. I have no problem using both for productivity work.

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_keyboards_side

The Switch Alpha 12’s keyboard is a bit thicker though, as seen above (the right side) which will contribute to the overall thickness of the device when folded and carried around.

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_acer_raised_keyboard

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_sp4_raised_keyboard

When the keyboard is attached at an angle to the body, the Switch Alpha 12 (top picture) hangs a bit higher off the ground. If you like to tilt the keyboard, you may prefer the Acer’s implementation slightly over the Microsoft’s. Both keyboards flexes slightly when you type at a full speed. But perhaps due to its additional thickness, the Switch Alpha 12’s keyboard flexes less.

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_as12_pen_holder

Someone from Acer must have had a “Oops” moment. This pen holder is definitely an afterthought invention. The Surface Pro 4’s magnet based solution is far more elegant.

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_acer_screen_gap

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_sp4_screen_gap

I was curious how close the bottom of the screen was when the keyboard is attached to the body, at a raised position. This is because I have some problem touching the bottom area of the screen when the keyboard is attached this way. And if you look at the above two pictures, it appears that the Acer has slightly bigger gap and this is actually the case. I do feel slightly more comfortable touching the bottom area of the screen. If you like switching between apps using your finger, you may like the Acer more.

 

Surface Pro 4 vs Acer Switch Alpha 12 – Kickstand

There’s a definite difference between these two models. Perhaps visually this is where they differentiate the most.

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_acer_sidekick_lowest.jpg

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_sp4_sidekick_lowest.jpg

Here’s how each device look when the kickstand is positioned at the lowest possible position. If you had to measure it, the Acer’s implementation allows for slightly lower position (less than 1/4 of an inch). Both feel solid without any give when set at this position.

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_acer_standing

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_sp4_standing

Once again, both offer a solid support when the kickstand is positioned at a more reasonable angle for a typical work. Since the Acer does not use a piece of flat board as a kickstand, you may find some situation where it may not offer as solid support if the ground is not level or is soft.

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_sidekick_bump

When the kickstand is completely folded in, the Surface Pro 4 offers a complete flushed look. As you can see above, the Acer’s implementation results in a small bump at the bottom. I could definitely see this as a high wear and tear area of the device because of this. I much prefer the Surface Pro 4’s implementation.

 

Surface Pro 4 vs Acer Switch Alpha 12 – Power Supply

Since these devices are meant for ultra portability, their included power supplies must be light and slim to carry around, right? Well, sort of…

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_power_supply

The Surface Pro 4’s power supply looks huge compared to the Switch Alpha 12’s when you look at them from this angle. But what about the rest?

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_acer_power_supply2 sp4_vs_acer_sa12_sp4_power_supply2

The left is the Switch Alpha 12 and the right is the Surface Pro 4. As you can see, the Microsoft’s version is far more elegant and simple. Acer’s cable is thick and less flexible. Have a look at them from this angle:

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_acer_power_supply sp4_vs_acer_sa12_sp4_power_supply

The Surface Pro 4’s power supply is bigger but also the height is lower. With much thicker wires on the Acer’s, I would say Microsoft’s power supply is easier one of the two to carry around. Although not obvious from these pictures, the Microsoft’s cable is actually flat.

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_power_supply_length

But as a bonus, the Acer’s cable is longer (by a good margin) if you need that extra reach. A point to Acer.

Also it is worth mentioning that the Switch Alpha 12’s power connector at the body is rudimentary at best as seen here:

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_acer_power_connect

When someone trips over the wire, I’m pretty sure your Switch Alpha 12 will fly across the room as well (ok, a bit of a exaggeration). Microsoft’s solution is far more elegant and functional.

 

Surface Pro 4 vs Acer Switch Alpha 12 – Weight

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_acer_weight sp4_vs_acer_sa12_sp4_weight

When each units are measured with their keyboard attached, the Surface Pro 4 is lighter. The Switch Alpha 12 weighs 2lb 13.3oz while the Surface Pro 4 weighs 2 lb 6.8oz. But that’s not the end of the story….

sp4_vs_acer_sa12_acer_weight_all sp4_vs_acer_sa12_sp4_weight_all

When the power supplies are included into the picture, the gap widens. Now, the Switch Alpha 12 weighs 3lb 7.5oz while the Surface Pro 4 weighs only 2lb 13.9oz.

 

 

Surface Pro 4 vs Acer Switch Alpha 12 – Design & Feel Conclusion

You can probably tell where Acer cut their corners to save cost by looking at these pictures. If none of these points concern you, this may be the model for you. Otherwise, you will have to carefully weigh the cost vs value proposition on each models.

 

More comparison articles on the Surface Pro 4 vs Acer Switch Alpha 12 focusing on other areas will follow shortly. Stay Tuned!

 


9 COMMENTS

  1. Hey, I don’t know what is lb and oz, but the Acer stuff looks crappy however Surface is elegant. To be honest Acer Switch comparing to the Surface seems like a 5 year old Huawei versus a Galaxy Note 7.

  2. Nice review.
    I like that you looked at the distance between the bottom of the screen and the keyboard in the folded up position.

    Regarding the cables: The SP4 has the longer cable on the device end and while the wall end is short, you can get a cable of nearly any length you need for very little money. I replaced mine with a 2m cable and that’s enough for practically any situation.

    • I just tried it. It doesn’t work. First of all, the magnets must be located at different positions as the keyboard doesn’t ‘snap’ into the right place and second of all, even when it is connected at a flat position, the keyboard doesn’t respond…

  3. This may be a bit off topic but, how do you feel about the Surface Pro 4 keyboard compared to the Surface Pro 3 keyboard in terms of typing experience? I’ve handled the Pro 4’s keyboard at a local store before, but not enough to draw a final conclusion. I wasn’t very impressed though and may feel like the more spaced out and what appear to be chiclet keys actually make a worse typing experience for me.

    • I personally don’t have enough experience with SP3 to comment on this but I have zero problem typing at full speed with the SP4 keyboard even though it does feel a bit flimsy. As I mentioned in this article, the SP4 keyboard flexes a bit more.

Leave a Reply